Coordinating Goals, Preferences, Options, and Analyses for the Stanford Living Laboratory Feasibility Study

TitleCoordinating Goals, Preferences, Options, and Analyses for the Stanford Living Laboratory Feasibility Study
Publication TypeTechnical Report
AuthorsHaymaker, J., and J. Chachere
NumberTR181
Date Published03/2009
Abstract

This paper describes an initial application of Multi-Attribute Collective Decision Analysis for a Design Initiative (MACDADI) on the feasibility study of a mixed-use facility. First, observations of the difficulties the design team experienced communicating their goals, preferences, options, and analyses are presented. Next, the paper describes a formal intervention by the authors, integrating survey, interview, and analytic methods. The project team collected, synthesized, and hierarchically organized their goals; stakeholdersí established their relative preferences with respect to these goals; the design team formally rated the design options with respect to the goals; the project team then visualized and assessed the goals, options, preferences, and analyses to assist in a transparent and formal decision making process. A discussion of some of the strengths and weaknesses of the MACDADI process is presented and opportunities for future improvement are identified.

KeywordsCoordination, Decision Analysis, Decision Based Design, Design, Design Rationale, MADCADI, Planning, Process Modeling, Process Models, Product Model, Validation, VDC, Virtual Design and Construction
Year of Publication2009
AttachmentSize
TR181.pdf210.06 KB

Last modified Mon, 21 Mar, 2011 at 16:05